FREE 9/23 MLB Cheat Sheet: Top DFS Plays
September 23, 2024

Today, we have a 4-game MLB slate on DraftKings, starting at 6:40 p.m. ET. Check out my favorite players at each position, value plays, and stacks! Our partners at DFSHero.com provide us with access to their lineup optimizer and AI simulator, which we use to provide you with the best DFS plays every day!
SP:
Eduardo Rodriguez, Arizona Diamondbacks (FD:$7,500 | DK:$6,500)
Aaron Nola, Philadelphia Phillies (FD:$10,500 | DK:$8,600)
Hunter Brown Houston Astros (FD:$9,300 | DK:$9,000)
Notes: Rodriguez is the number one ranked SP tonight on the DFS Hero Optimizer. Nola is the number two-ranked SP. Brown is the number five ranked SP tonight on the Optimizer but has an excellent matchup against a weak-hitting Mariners team. The Optimizer likes Chris Bassitt and Tanner Houck as well, ranking them as the number 3 and 4 pitchers.
Top Stacks:
Diamondbacks vs. Giants
Secondary Stack:
Phillies vs. Cubs
Notes: These are two of the best lineups in the National League, and with the slate being so small tonight, there really aren’t any better choices. There is no reason to get cute here.
C:
JT Realmuto Philadelphia Phillies (FD:$3,000 | DK:$4,200)
Yainer Diaz, Houston Astros (FD:$3,100 | DK:$4,600)
Connor Wong, Boston Red Sox (FD:$2,800 | DK:$3,700)
Notes: Realmuto can be used in the Phillies stack tonight, and he is one of the best-hitting catchers in MLB. He is the number 1 ranked catcher on the Optimizer as well. Diaz is the number two ranked catcher on the Optimizer, and Wong is the number 4 ranked catcher.
1B:
Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Toronto Blue Jayss (FD:$3,900 | DK:$5,200)
Bryce Harper, Philadelphia Phillies (FD:$3,700 | DK:$5,400)
Christian Walker, Arizona Diamondbacks (FD:$3,400 | DK:$4,900)
Notes: Vlad is the number 1 ranked 1B on the DFS Hero Optimizer today. Harper can be used in the Phillies stack and is ranked 4th on the Optimizer. Walker can be used in the D-Backs stack and is the number 2 ranked 1B on the Optimizer.
2B:
Jose Altuve, Houston Astros (FD:$3,400 | DK:$5,000)
Ketel Marte, Arizona Diamondbacks (FD:$4,300 | DK:$6,000)
Bryson Stott, Philadelphia Phillies (FD:$2,900 | DK:$4,300)
Notes: Altuve is the number 1 ranked 2B on the Simulator tonight. Stott is the number 4 ranked 2B on the DFS Hero Simulator, can be used in the Phillies stack, and has a 22.5% chance to 3X. Marte is one of the best-hitting 2B in the league this season and can be used in the D-Backs stack. I have a player listed in the value section, too.
3B:
Eugenio Suarez, Arizona Diamondbackss (FD:3,600 | DK:$4,700)
Alec Bohm, Philadelphia Phillies (FD:$3,300 | DK:$4,400)
Notes: Both players can be used in my top stacks tonight. Bohm is the number 2 ranked 3B on the Simulator. I also have a value option. The Simulator also likes Matt Chapman and Alex Bregman.
SS:
Trea Turner, Philadelphia Phillies (FD:$3,800 | DK:$5,700)
Geraldo Perdomo, Arizona Diamondbacks (FD:$2,800 | DK:$3,500)
Tyler Fitzgerald, San Francisco Giants (FD:$3,300 | DK:$4,400)
Notes: Turner is the number-ranked SS on the DFS Hero Simulator today and can be used in the Phillies stack. Fitzgerald is the 2nd ranked SS on the simulator tonight and has a 26% chance to 3X. Perdomo can be used as a cheap option in the D-Backs stack and has a 24% chance to 3X.
OF:
Kyle Schwarber, Philadelphia Phillies (FD:$4,000 | DK:$5,900)
Nick Castellanos, Philadelphia Phillies (FD:$3,00 | DK:$4,100)
Brandon Marsh, Philadelphia Phillies (FD:$2,900 | DK:$3,900)
Corbin Carroll, Arizona Diamondbacks (FD:$3,900 | DK:$5,300)
Joc Pederson, Arizona Diamondbacks (FD:$3,300 | DK:$4,600)
Jake McCarthy, Arizona Diamondbacks (FD:$2,800 | DK:$4,000)
Notes: These are my favorite OF options in my top stacks tonight. The Simulator also likes Julio Rodriguez, Kyle Tucker, Randy Arozarena, and Yordan Alvarez.
Value Players:
2B/3B Casey Schmitt, San Francisco Giants (FD:$2,200 | DK:$2,300)
2B/3B Romy Gonzalez, Boston Red Sox (FD:$2,500 | DK:$3,300)
SS Trevor Story, Boston Red Sox (FD:$2,900 | DK:$3,400)
OF Davis Schneider, Toronto Blue Jays (FD:$2,600 | DK:$3,40)
Notes: Schmitt has a 42% chance to 3X tonight, and Gonzalez has a 33% chance to 3X tonight. Thanks to their position eligibility, you can play them both in the same lineup if necessary. Story is the 4th ranked SS on the Simulator tonight, but he has a 31% chance to 3X. Schnieder has a 27% chance to 3X tonight and a 19% chance to 3.5X.
Please note: The content in our articles is based on data available at the time of publishing. Always double-check your lineups before locking in your players.